Free checklist Β· MCP gateway evaluation

The MCP Gateway Checklist

Evaluating an MCP gateway? Check it against 63 criteria across 13 areas, from MCP server hosting and registry to OAuth, guardrails, observability, and agents.

No paywall Works for any MCP gateway Built for platform and AI teams
  • Self-service registration for hosted MCP servers
  • SSO and OAuth2 through your identity provider
  • RBAC down to individual MCP tools
  • End-to-end tracing across model and tool calls

What the checklist covers:

63

Criteria to evaluate an MCP gateway against, each with the exact question to ask

13

Areas, from MCP server hosting and registry to agents and enterprise needs

45

Criteria rated must have before an MCP gateway is ready for production

3

Priority levels: must have, nice to have, and depends on use case

Inside the checklist

Download the checklist to get:

A structured framework to compare MCP gateways and spot the gaps before you commit.

Download the Checklist

βœ“

The full 63-point MCP gateway checklist

Every criterion grouped into 13 areas, with the question to put to each vendor.

βœ“

A priority rating for every criterion

Know which capabilities are must have, which are nice to have, and which depend on your use case.

βœ“

Security and access criteria for MCP

How to evaluate SSO, OAuth2, dynamic client registration, tool-level RBAC, and credential rotation.

βœ“

Criteria for the playground and agent registry

How to test tools safely, publish agents with guardrails bundled, and version them over time.

Why it matters

Why MCP Needs a Gateway

The Model Context Protocol made it easy for agents to call tools. That's also the problem. Every team spins up its own MCP servers, every agent connects to them directly, and each connection carries its own API keys or tokens. Platform and security teams lose sight of which tools exist, who can call them, and what those calls did.

An MCP gateway puts one control layer between agents and tools. It hosts and registers MCP servers, authenticates every user and agent through your identity provider, enforces RBAC down to individual tools, applies guardrails and rate limits, and traces every call for audit. But gateways differ a lot in how deep each of these goes.

Agents & apps IDEs Β· copilots Β· agents MCP Gateway registry Β· catalog SSO Β· OAuth2 tool-level RBAC guardrails rate limits Β· tracing Hosted MCP servers Remote MCP servers & tools LLM providers one endpoint Deployed as managed cloud, in your VPC, on-prem, or hybrid

One gateway between your agents and every MCP server, tool, and model they call.

How to use the checklist

Each of the 63 criteria names one capability, the question to put to a vendor, and a priority: must have, nice to have, or depends on use case. Score every MCP gateway on your shortlist against the same list, starting with the 45 must haves. The gaps show up before you commit.

Want help running the evaluation? Reach out to anuraag@truefoundry.com for a 30-minute personalized walkthrough.

Preview

Inside the MCP gateway checklist

A sample of the criteria in six of the 13 areas. The full checklist includes all 63, with priorities.

Hosting Β· 4 criteria

MCP server deployment and hosting

Containerized MCP servers deployed on Kubernetes or VMs

Zero-downtime rollouts with blue/green or canary deploys

+2 more criteria

Registry Β· 4 criteria

MCP registry

Self-service registration via UI, API, or GitOps

Support for HTTP and STDIO transports

+2 more criteria

Auth Β· 5 criteria

Authorization and authentication

SSO through Okta, Google Workspace, or Azure AD

Dynamic client registration with your identity provider

+3 more criteria

Playground Β· 8 criteria

Playground support

Tool access in the playground governed by registry RBAC

Code snippets for Python, Node.js, LangChain, and LangGraph

+6 more criteria

Security Β· 4 criteria

Guardrails and security

Detection of prompt injection, data exfiltration, and jailbreaks

MCP servers sandboxed with auth, RBAC, and network isolation

+2 more criteria

Observability Β· 6 criteria

Audit and observability

Audit logs for every prompt, tool call, and admin action

Export to OpenTelemetry, Prometheus, Datadog, or Splunk

+4 more criteria

Also covers: MCP marketplace (5) Β· Agent registry (4) Β· Rate limiting (4) Β· Ecosystem and integration (6) Β· Performance and scalability (4) Β· Gateway deployment and configuration (6) Β· Enterprise considerations (3)

9.9

β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

Highly rated on G2

Trusted by leading enterprises

Teams at NVIDIA, Merck, Synopsys, Siemens Healthineers, NetApp, and Zscaler trust TrueFoundry. Its AI Gateway brings models, MCP servers, and agents under one control layer, with reliability, observability, and security built in.

GartnerIDC Innovator 2024G2 Momentum LeaderG2 Best Est. ROISOC 2HIPAA

MCP gateway FAQ

What is an MCP gateway?

An MCP gateway sits between your agents and the MCP servers and tools they call. It hosts and registers MCP servers, authenticates users and agents through your identity provider, enforces RBAC down to individual tools, applies guardrails and rate limits, and traces every tool call for audit.

Why do teams need an MCP gateway?

Without a gateway, every agent connects to every MCP server directly, each with its own credentials. That leaves no central view of which tools exist, who can call them, or what they did. An MCP gateway gives platform and security teams one place to govern MCP access.

What are the must-have features of an MCP gateway?

45 of the 63 criteria in the checklist are rated must have. They include containerized MCP server deployment, self-service registration, RBAC, SSO and OAuth2, secure credential management, end-to-end tracing, audit logs, AI-specific threat detection, per-tool quotas, and flexible deployment options.

Does the checklist cover agents and the playground?

Yes. It includes eight playground criteria, such as LLM switching, tool access with RBAC, and code snippet generation, and four agent registry criteria, including publishing, discoverability, access control, and versioning.

Can I use the checklist to evaluate any MCP gateway?

Yes. The criteria apply to any MCP gateway, whether commercial, open source, or built in house.